Ny Times Review of Opera Cosi Van Tutte
Review: Proficient intentions don't salve Edmonton Opera's Così fan tutte from its stereotyped roots
Reviews and recommendations are unbiased and products are independently selected. Postmedia may earn an affiliate commission from purchases made through links on this page.
The intentions for Edmonton Opera'due south new production of Mozart's opera Così fan tutte are boldly stated in the very start bar of the overture.
There, in the surtitles above the stage, appears the opera's title (which means 'All women are like that,') merely crossed out. Underneath is a new title, Così fan tutti, and its translation, 'We are all similar that'.
For the avowed intent of this production, which opened at the Jubilee Saturday nighttime, was to shake off the fur coat of misogyny in which the opera is and then often clothed, and give the women an agency the music suggests they deserve.
It promised much, with two women — director Kim Mattice Wanat and conductor Cosette Justo Valdés — making their company debuts.
Both the designers are also women, and their work immediately catches the eye. Deanna Finnman'southward costumes perfectly suggest a flow which one might depict as Jane Austen for older audiences, and pseudo-Bridgerton for younger ones, with the male lovers in the bright colourful uniforms of the Napoleonic Wars.
Brianna Kolybaba's phase designs have a uncomplicated and elegant Regency season, though the landscape backdrops suggest more than of a fairytale tone.
Simply soon cracks in these conceptions beginning appearing. The maid Despina, played past soprano Caitlin Wood, is transformed into a kind of cupid figure, and to show the audience this, she changes costumes.
She does this not merely a few times, but again and again and again, at the side of the stage, eventually with a flurry that threatened to break whatever record for the most on-phase costume changes in the shortest space of fourth dimension.
Those costumes were visually arresting, merely so were the actions when they shouldn't have been. They became more and more annoying, especially when done during important, introvert arias. Putting Despina right at the side of the stage for these changes was a mistake — the eye is designed to be distracted past motion in the periphery vision.
It also soon became apparent that the setting, and indeed the whole stage action, merely didn't belong on a stage this size, especially when the chorus had been cut from the opera. The six players were dwarfed, and actions became repetitive and increasingly stagey (how many drinks did they take on stage?)
Worst of all was the carmine mantle that regularly descended for set changes, with a couple of singers in front of it. Not just was the huge swathe of cherry visually distracting, only information technology wasn't clear why it was needed at all, particularly equally some set-change elements were intentionally visible.
A black gauze did come downwardly briefly at ane point, for no apparent reason, so couldn't the scene changes accept been done behind that? Every bit it was, that red curtain spoiled the sense of theatrical involvement and broke the menses.
This all might not accept mattered if there had been compelling singing and acting and orchestral sound. However, these areas also seemed to suffer similar contradictions: promising elements that were confounded past mixed results.
With two pairs of lovers, each of the iv had their vocal moments, specially the pleasing tone of soprano Jennifer Taverner as Fiordiligi, and the Guglielmo of Clarence Frazer. Just the two fiancées came across, alas, as pretty vacuous women, with little in their trunk linguistic communication or vocal acting to propose something feistier. They were given swords to play with, in a fairly obvious Freudian reference, simply the sight of Fiordiligi belongings hers loftier as if she was some queen heroine nearly to fight the Romans was risible.
Those swords were eventually substituted with parasols, which virtually summed up the confusion in the production. As the evening dragged on, the men resorted to more and more than stagey, stereotyped comedic poses.
In the pit, Justo Valdés, conducting her offset mainstage opera, was hampered from the outset by a modest orchestra of nineteen players. In spite of some fine instrumental efforts, they simply couldn't produce the kind of audio Mozart's score, and the cavernous Jubilee, require.
The event was orchestral playing that was all on much the aforementioned dynamic, with fiddling variation or dash, not helped at times by some very boring tempi.
Fortunately, 1 operation shone through this. Wood one time again showed her skills at putting across feeling through the voice, as well as her considerable interim abilities and stage presence. Over again, though, the production resorts to comic stereotypes when she pretends to be the apothecary or the notary. One had hoped for something more than inventive, but the song distortions could have come direct out of a Rossini one-act.
I could not sympathise why this product carried a alarm that information technology was merely appropriate for patrons aged 10 and older unless Edmonton Opera was acknowledging the misogynistic elements. Clearly, the visitor's new artistic manager Joel Ivany didn't, either, as he announced his eight-twelvemonth-onetime son was in the audience.
If only at that place had been something a bit racier here, to salvage what ended upwards, alas, equally a dull evening.
Maybe there will exist more than sparkle in the performances on Tuesday and Friday, but I don't come across how that can really rescue the fundamentals here: misogynistic men, vacuous women, in a plodding, stereotyped world.
I left grateful that we are not all like that.
yegarts@postmedia.com
REVIEW
Mozart's Così fan tutte by Edmonton Opera
Director: Kim Mattice Wanat
Conductor: Cosette Justo Valdés
Starring: Neil Craighead, Clarence Frazer, Jennifer Taverner, Asitha Tennekoon, Stephanie Tritchew, and Caitlin Wood
Where: Jubilee Auditorium, 11455 87 Ave.
When: March 19
Adjacent performances: March 22 and 25
Tickets: Starting at $29 from edmontonopera.com
richardsoncantences.blogspot.com
Source: https://edmontonjournal.com/entertainment/local-arts/review-good-intentions-dont-rescue-edmonton-operas-cosi-fan-tutte-from-its-stereotyped-roots
0 Response to "Ny Times Review of Opera Cosi Van Tutte"
Post a Comment